Percy Bysshe Shelley

To Jane: 'The keen stars were twinkling

strings without soul

The guitar is literally soulless until she plays it. Shelley's making an Aristotelian argument: her voice is the form that gives matter (strings) its essence.

I
The keen stars were twinkling,
And the fair moon was rising among them,
Dear Jane!

Dear Jane!

Jane Williams, wife of Shelley's friend Edward. Shelley was infatuated with her in his final months—he drowned three months after writing this. The exclamation mark appears in all five stanzas.

The guitar was tinkling,
But the notes were not sweet till you sung them
Again.
II
As the moon's soft splendour
O'er the faint cold starlight of Heaven
Is thrown,
So your voice most tender

strings without soul

The guitar is literally soulless until she plays it. Shelley's making an Aristotelian argument: her voice is the form that gives matter (strings) its essence.

To the strings without soul had then given
Its own.
III
The stars will awaken,
Though the moon sleep a full hour later.

the moon sleep a full hour later

Moonset happens roughly 50 minutes later each night. He's asking her to keep singing past when the moon goes down—literally asking for overtime.

To-night;
No leaf will be shaken
Whilst the dews of your melody scatter
Delight.

strings without soul

The guitar is literally soulless until she plays it. Shelley's making an Aristotelian argument: her voice is the form that gives matter (strings) its essence.

IV
Though the sound overpowers,
Sing again, with your dear voice revealing
A tone
Of some world far from ours,
Where music and moonlight and feeling

music and moonlight and feeling / Are one

Shelley's idealism in miniature: a world where subjective experience (feeling) and objective reality (moonlight) merge. Compare his 'Defence of Poetry' written the same year.

music and moonlight and feeling / Are one

Shelley's idealism in miniature: a world where subjective experience (feeling) and objective reality (moonlight) merge. Compare his 'Defence of Poetry' written the same year.

Are one.
Source Wikipedia Poetry Foundation

Reading Notes

The Jane Williams Context

CONTEXT Shelley wrote this in 1822, living in Italy with Mary Shelley and the Williams couple. Edward Williams owned a guitar that Jane played. Shelley was writing her constant poems—at least six survive from these final months.

The poem is a serenade, but notice what it's not: there's no request for romantic favor, no complaint about unrequited love. Instead, it's structured as aesthetic theory. The core claim appears in stanza II: her voice gives soul to soulless strings, the way moonlight transforms starlight rather than replacing it.

Shelley repeats the entire poem twice in the manuscript, unusual even for him. Some editors print it once, some twice. The repetition might be musical instruction (play it as a round?) or revision anxiety, but it also enacts the poem's request: 'Sing again.'

Sound Engineering

The rhyme scheme is ABABCB with truncated lines—each stanza has two short lines (3-4 syllables) that rhyme. This creates a tinkling effect, mimicking the guitar. Notice 'twinkling/tinkling' in stanza I: the stars and guitar share the same sound pattern.

Shelley loads the poem with liquid consonants (l, m, n) and soft fricatives (s, f): 'moon's soft splendour,' 'faint cold starlight,' 'voice most tender.' Even the harder sounds get softened—'keen stars' has that long 'ee' vowel smoothing the 'k' and 'st' clusters.

The word 'overpowers' in stanza IV breaks the pattern—it's the poem's only moment of force. But immediately he asks her to sing 'again,' returning to the gentle register. The technical point: her voice is powerful precisely because it's tender, not despite it.